Comstock Won’t Come to You, But You Can Go to Her

untitled

No amount of “constituent services” can make up for this one, giant DIS-service.

Sterling, VA| Barbara Comstock continues to assert that she can best help her constituents by meeting with small groups of no more than five people at a time. To be fair, she can probably do some good work for folks who visit what amounts to “Comstock’s Constituent Services Boutique.” For example, when a caller from the last tele-Town Hall mentioned how she was paying the full cost of being on the ACA exchange, despite being unemployed, the Congresswoman invited her to come into her office, saying, “We need to figure out what plan you’re on and see if there are existing subsidies that you’re eligible for that you could get.” tele-town-hall-minutes-2-21-2017-final

Assisting individual people with their problems is a great thing to do. However, among Members of Congress, constituent services are not an exception, they’re the rule. Every office has staff devoted to this issue, and it’s used for a variety of services, including nominating candidates to be admitted to West Point and flying ceremonial flags over the Capitol. Ms. Comstock is hardly alone in working to help people who find themselves needing a nomination, a letter of congratulation, or help finding their way out of any given bureaucratic labyrinth.

The question is, just how helpful are these services to the district at large, and can they take the place of a real, in-person Town Hall?

Consider this: at last night’s citizen-led Town Hall event, which Comstock declined to attend, the task of answering the audience’s questions fell to teams of constituent researchers. Though well-prepared for the job, these citizen researchers simply couldn’t answer some questions for which Ms. Comstock has never issued a statement, or voted on. If Ms. Comstock had been there, she could have answered for herself, and many constituents would have had the opportunity to get to know her positions better. These answers would have been amplified by the press and traveled through the news-wires to residents of the district at-large. In contrast, though a group of 5 people could try and spread the word about their meeting with the Congresswoman, the likelihood of thousands of people paying attention to their message is miniscule.

 

empty-slide
Some questions can only be answered by Comstock, herself/photo: Wendy Wendigo.

 

A Congresswoman who imperiously sits in her office in the Capitol and demands small groups of people take the day off work to make the long trip into D.C. for a 15-minute meeting with her to discuss their concerns or seek her help, automatically disqualifies many of the constituents who need her help the most. These are the people who were represented last night by Matthew Zellman, of Centreville, who approached the microphone and said,

“I’m here for the people who are too scared to come (and for whom it’s too dangerous to come). Centreville is diverse. My son’s friend has undocumented parents. They came here legally but were unable to maintain that status because the system is broken. My family is really close to them. They pay taxes, attend church, work hard; they’re about as American as anyone I’ve ever met. Do you consider those people to be criminals just by being virtue of being victims of our broken system? Do you support using our tax money to detain and deport and imprison them, and bog down our justice system? Or do you think they deserve a path to citizenship?”

Should Mr. Zellman have taken a day off from work to ask Ms. Comstock these questions? In fact, should anyone have to skip out on their job in order for Barbara to do hers?

Those seeking to defend Ms. Comstock’s continued refusal to hold a Town Hall do so by asserting that calls for a Town Hall are nothing more than a ploy by the Organized Left, posting statements to her social media such as, “We open the newspaper every morning to read about all the republican town halls across the country with matching signs, matching chants and matching behavior, laid out by a paid group of organizers, “Indivisible” with the goal of creating camera-ready chaos.”

Defending Rep. Comstock by casting aspersions on her constituents is not a good campaign strategy. The Washington Post, who aptly called last night’s event a “sedate forum,” wrote, “At times, the event on Comstock’s turf seemed more like a policy seminar than a protest.” In fact, it was never meant to be a protest or publicity stunt. There were no cardboard cut-outs of the Congresswoman, no empty suit hung in her chair, and attendees were strongly discouraged from bringing signs or chanting slogans. In explaining why she wouldn’t come, Ms. Comstock stated, “I think things could get partisan,” after criticizing moderator Todd Kliman for being a “Food critic from Maryland.” In reality, Mr. Kliman emceed the event with grace and aplomb, asking for a show of hands for opinions at times, and keeping the event moving at a good pace. In a span of two hours, 32 questions were addressed. In comparison, Comstock was only able to answer half that amount at her tele-Town Hall, which lasted almost as long.

 

show-of-hands
Who, here, is upset by Comstock’s votes against Clean Water?/photo: Wendy Wendigo

 

By the event’s end, many attendees had a greater understanding of Ms. Comstock and her votes. Addressing comments directly to Comstock’s empty chair, Kathy Stewart, of Sterling, said, “Your votes on Education bills prior to and since [the Trump administration] are shocking to me, and I didn’t know about them,” and Matthew Zellman said, “Honestly I barely knew who you were before this last election.”

 

empty-chair
The reserved seat for Comstock remained empty/photo: Wendy Wendigo

 

Having gotten as much information as possible from Comstock’s past statements and voting records, the audience stacked up their chairs and prepared to leave. As they headed out into the night, the first part of Kathy Stewart’s earlier question was probably echoing in their minds: “Barbara Comstock, when are you going to start legislating for us?”

4 thoughts on “Comstock Won’t Come to You, But You Can Go to Her

  1. That’s how my mother and I spent my only day off on 5 days we drove a little over two hours for a meeting that was supposed to be at 1. The only way I even knew she was taking meetings that day was because of an indivisible 10 Facebook group I joined because I had been trying to speak with representative Comstock since November. I emailed them around 11am last Thursday I got a response with a time to meet around 6pm Thursday. I then had to provide information so that they would be ready when I got there Friday. I was lucky I was off work that day or I wouldn’t have gotten a meeting even though I watched the town hall held by indivisible 10 members for representative Comstock and it provided more information than my meeting. Anyway we got to D.C. at 1230 we quickly were met with a parking pass. We parked and we’re in Comstock’s office at 1245 she’s running behind because that day she was taking all this little meetings. I think it was almost 3 when we got to talk to representative Comstock. I was concerned about the repeal of the ACA and environmental concerns. We talked a few minutes maybe 20 she was nice but in reality she was feeding me a bunch of falsehoods. I don’t have the time to be using my days off driving almost 5 hours round trip to meet my representative when there is an office 15 minutes from my house. She needs to have a town hall in Winchester and sterling where her offices and constituents are not in a cramped office in DC hours away from her constituents she works for us not the other way around

    Like

    1. I’m so sorry she put you through that. I agree – a Town Hall in Winchester would be a wonderful thing. We will keep pressuring her to hold one. Thank you for taking the time to go and speak to her about your concerns – trekking to the Capitol office is an all-day ordeal!

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s